Content
@
0 reply
20 recasts
20 reactions
ted (not lasso)
@ted
can someone steel man the arguments FOR and AGAINST all non-warpcast farcaster clients integrating XMTP group messaging capabilities? (i probably should’ve done some research before casting this) cc @shanemac.eth
10 replies
1 recast
21 reactions
Greg
@greg
better than each client building their own chat system
1 reply
0 recast
10 reactions
Haole
@haole
Most people are using Warpcast. If Warpcast doesn't support XMTP and you DM someone on a third-party app, you might never get a response.
0 reply
0 recast
3 reactions
Cassie Heart
@cassie
for: - composability, broader ecosystem - killer bizdev team has network effects (seriously @shanemac.eth is a master at this and it should be something HBS grads study instead of regurgitating their normal bullshit like telling jeff bezos to sell early AMZN to barnes and noble) against: - spam controls become deeply fragmented, warpcast is easy to nerf wallet drainer dc spam (and we've had to already) - MLS for group chats doesn't work in the decentralized model, the approach they're going to use is via smart contract to stand in place as the "centralized" host, which is subject to reorgs and can be fragile (and if not, is very slow waiting for sufficient epochs) - tighter integration with other hub features, current and future (say more won't get more here 🤫)
1 reply
0 recast
12 reactions
agusti 🐘
@bleu.eth
against warpcast won’t
1 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
ns
@nickysap
For: easier to message people based on their ens. Can be useful for things like attribution (someone minted something you liked). Against: not really purposeful beyond that. Probably a relatively large dev lift for limited outcome I’m probably missing use cases but that’s my kneejerk response
0 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
FlexasaurusRex◨-◨Ⓜ️🎩
@flexasaurusrex
is XMTP open source for them to do so though regardless if its a good idea or not?
0 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
Gramajo👽
@gramajo.eth
I’ve asked this as well before but from what I recall. All the devs of all the apps/clients would need to align to use xmtp or else we would have fragmentation where some use it and some don’t. So they all need coordination for it to be a win for all or else it’s busy work for no clear win
0 reply
0 recast
1 reaction
Philip Sheldrake
@sheldrake
I wonder why XMTP comes up so often in a world in which we have matrix.org.
0 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
Rafaello.base.eth
@rafaello12
Just googled what XMTP means, first time hearing about it
0 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
WetSocks💦🧦
@wetsocks.eth
yeah i got you jus gimme a bit
1 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
