Farcaster

If you like the recent channel changes, reply to this cast. Sharing a reason is particularly helpful.

Still a bunch to improve, but worth surfacing what's working for people.

Looking for people who are frustrated with the changes and new direction for channels.

Last week, we got a lot of good feedback from people happy with / excited about the changes. See below. Now I want to highlight what's still not working for people.

Specifically:

1. What's frustrating? 

2. What would make it better?

Looking for people who are frustrated with the changes and new direction for channels.

Last week, we got a lot of good feedback from people happy with / excited about the changes. See below. Now I want to highlight what's still not working for people.

Specifically:

1. What's frustrating? 

2. What would make it better?

https://warpcast.com/dwr.eth/0xcf622e07

I'm eth newbie..just learning
(working on @farcaster)

terminally.online

I didn't obsess over permissionless platforms so I could ask permission 🤷‍♂️

What's frustrating? The fact that we need permission from a small handful of mods to access a supposed permissionless social network. I don't care about being "in the club", I just want to read and talk about things I find interesting.

"Ohh but channels are like twitter spaces now!" Ok WHY? Twitter spaces suck ( a few people talking while everybody is just in the audience). Why is this the direction? What wasn't working with channels that they needed to be like Twitter spaces? Was it merely the spam / low effort content?

What's frustrating? The fact that we need permission from a small handful of mods to access a supposed permissionless social network. I don't care about being "in the club", I just want to read and talk about things I find interesting.

"Ohh but channels are like twitter spaces now!" Ok WHY? Twitter spaces suck ( a few people talking while everybody is just in the audience). Why is this the direction? What wasn't working with channels that they needed to be like Twitter spaces? Was it merely the spam / low effort content?

https://warpcast.com/superphiz.eth/0xeeea1f28

"Channels are walled gardens"

1. Everyone can read and reply to channel casts

2. Most people appear above the fold when replying

3. The cast data is on the protocol, you're able to build a client or another experience with it that you think is better

4. There are plenty of channels experimenting with token and NFT gating.

5. I'll repeat: *there is no distribution boost to casting in a channel*. It's strictly if you want to take the time to start building relationships in that community (which you can start today by replying to any cast in the channel).

6. A generic topic / hashtag like #ai, #food, #founders is not a community. It's an attempt at boosting distribution. And we're specifically not boosting distribution. So casting in your home feed (to your followers) will get you the same distribution to people who already choose to follow you.

See below for context.

What channels were you actively casting in before that you can’t now?

Permissionless platform refers to 1) sign up 2) casting 3) building your own client.

Re Twitter Space — It’s an analogy to help people understand.

We ran channels for a year life hashtags, very few ended up good. People treated them like hashtags vs. communities. So we were unable to boost casts in channels.

See below for context.

What channels were you actively casting in before that you can’t now?

Permissionless platform refers to 1) sign up 2) casting 3) building your own client.

Re Twitter Space — It’s an analogy to help people understand.

We ran channels for a year life hashtags, very few ended up good. People treated them like hashtags vs. communities. So we were unable to boost casts in channels.

https://warpcast.com/dwr.eth/0x2b1ab535

Food

crypto

EthFinance

> What channels were you actively casting in before that you can’t now?

A handful, though that is irrelevant. Do we need permission to cast in channels or not?  It's analogous to every subreddit becoming private. It's not great.

> People treated them like hashtags vs. communities

ok so? More general channels (as you described, /food) will obviously be a catchall for generic casts. But more specific communities can emerge. /crypto vs /ethfinance for example.