Degen

here's a dune query where you can explore how banned users got and received tips

honestly, it seems many "tip4tip"-based bans seem harsh

https://dune.com/queries/4632109/7715212/

(cherrypicked) harsh t4t bans:

both @katekornish and @rjs got banned for t4t and neither of them received a tip from another banned account

i'd argue that t4t is a reciprocal thing so i'd expect there's at least one banned account that tipped them back. but that's not the case.

discuss (or not)

Classical musician and educator with psychology qualification. Teaching and playing worldwide. https://paragraph.xyz/@katekornish https://zora.co/@katekornish

Husband, dad, dev • @dune.eth wizard • Ultimate Ⓜ️oxie Dashboard https://tinyurl.com/moxiedash • Ultimate Degen Tips FAQ https://tinyurl.com/degenfaq

fortune cookie casts, memes, parenting, building frames, /framedl, /framedl-pro & /calmer

Careful, this is how you get yourself banned 😅

tech vs. absurd – you're not real – /sauce – /cto - /addresso

honestly, i don't know... it can go both ways. if the core user base is solid, it will strengthen it. if not, it'll fall apart.

in any case, we probably won't see any rapid user growth (unless degen moons), as this will very likely be discouraging for low effort accounts

what's the long term effect of the rules being too harsh in your opinion? complete stalemate?

Thanks for making this query! 

I see the same for a friend who was banned. Among all her tips sent and received, she's the only one banned. I know someone in her circle got unbanned, but there doesn't seem to be an official process by which that happens. Which makes things even more unfair.

I think the rules should be clear from the beginning, rather than punishing members for not following the rules that are laid out in the final days of the season. This is very bad for the trust of the community and makes everyone cynical.

It is as if this was done in a rush, accross the board, without taking into account the limitations of raw data import