Has anyone seen the Uniswap SDK return absolute garbage routes?

Here's a trade where the Uni UI offers ~$710

Uni SDK on the exact same trade finds a terrible route that pays only ~$410! Then you query it a few more times and it finds the correct one.

Real World Ethereum 🌎 
building /daimo ✳️ 

exploring the matrix onchain 🌀 | ops wizard 🪄 | hosting /defi • /the-glyph • /pixelglyphs • /autism


there are so many of these. odos, defillama, sushiswap, 0x, other aggregators.

does any of these have a concrete claim to being best or most reliable?

we chose Uniswap so far because it's lindy + the biggest + most liquid. genuinely surprised that the Uni router returns wrong prices.

use odos for best routes. or defillama swap.

Making the blockchain invisible at /thirdweb

I didn’t know the sdk even found multi hop routes for you, thought you had to provide the route yourself

fwiw I’ve found 0x/matcha easy to use and consitent

fwiw I’ve found 0x/matcha easy to use and consitent https://0x.org/docs/0x-swap-api/introduction

In our experience Uniswap SDK has been very not great. Feels like the SDK is not a revenue driver and thus it’s not maintained. cc @w

A little biased, but have you tried using the Matcha SDK for swapping? it's really simple to implement as it gives you the calldata for swapping directly

Traveling salesman problem is tough. How does Uniswap's SDK compare to this?

Josh's code builds a bunch of USDC/DAI/USDT pairs between the `to` and `from` tokens if you enable multi-hop routes.

Traveling salesman problem is tough. How does Uniswap's SDK compare to this?

Josh's code builds a bunch of USDC/DAI/USDT pairs between the `to` and `from` tokens if you enable multi-hop routes.

https://github.com/joshstevens19/simple-uniswap-sdk

All routers still catching up from last six months. Base been especially bad because aero just getting integrated