That said: podcasts, songs, pfps, clips from sports games, messaging, etc do not have onchain PMF.

Building @tipn /rebase | Advising /24art | Prev. @cent Nifty Gateway | Hosting /thewipmeetup | byteGAN #265 PFP by @vanarman

digital art as NFTs has financial aspects to it, but unfortunately it does not have onchain PMF. tiny volume and little demand.

Legitimately curious, how exactly do you define pmf? Obviously you factor a specific volume threshold into it but curious to know what that is 

I've always subscribed to the more general "being in a good market with a product that can satisfy that market" definition

🖼️ 24 HOURS OF ART 📊 May 2, 2025

🏢 Spaces Captivates
'Spaces' by @GrantYun2 with @fellowshiptrust concludes, selling 20 artworks for 253.95 ETH (~$471,000 USD) total.

5 Highlight Sales:
- 'Last Minute Groceries': 29.282 ETH
- 'Inflight Coffee': 25 ETH
- 'Lobby': 24 ETH to https://t.co/VtNv84XEUZ

clicking @clickerxyz (a @daylight ░░░░░░) | kylemccollom.com

Legitimately curious, how exactly do you define pmf? Obviously you factor a specific volume threshold into it but curious to know what that is 

I've always subscribed to the more general "being in a good market with a product that can satisfy that market" definition 
https://x.com/RogerDickerman/status/1918296113276244050?t=bURVeCZsqayAJZv2nZ6CvA&s=19

Digital art has repeatedly seen face ripping demand tho (i was there for it on multiple occasions and literally produced the $91M pak merge release that did $150k in sales per second when it went live) 

We have seen continued high demand sales events on primary and seconday as well over the last half decade

Obvi not going to convince you that digital art has pmf - to each their own - just more surprised you set the bar to define it so high