Content pfp
Content
@
0 reply
0 recast
0 reaction
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
Réalisme fantastique? The most important genre you've never heard of? A Christmas thread 🧵
1 reply
2 recasts
24 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
Let me introduce you to an obscure countercultural movement from the 1960s that I deem both underrated and perenially relevant. It originated from France under the name "réalisme fantastique" and is recondite enough that its French Wikipedia article does not have an English equivalent (though I'm thinking of creating one). 2/17
2 replies
0 recast
11 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
In fact, I struggle to even offer an adequate translation of "réalisme fantastique". The first part seems obvious enough; in the arts, realism spawned in the 1840s with a goal to represent subjects truthfully, devoid of any speculative or supernatural elements, as a reaction against the idealization and dramatization of the then-prevalent romanticism movement. 3/17
1 reply
0 recast
3 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
"Fantastique", on the other hand, has no equivalent in the English lexicon. It pertains to the subtle intrusion of supernatural elements into reality, but also, and very importantly, to the uncertainty that surrounds them. 4/17
1 reply
0 recast
3 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
Unlike the "merveilleux" or fantasy genre, which shares a latin root with "miraculous" and assumes a deeply magical world in which realistic normality may still exist, the "fantastique" genre plays on the blurred lines between natural and supernatural, the possible and the impossible, and the logical and the illogical. 5/17
1 reply
0 recast
3 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
An example of quintessential "fantastique" in popular culture is the TV show The X-Files; at least those episodes where there is enough plausible deniability for Scully to explain away the uncanny phenomena observed by Mulder. Like the viewer or reader, the protagonists of the fantastique genre *must* be reluctant to accept the supernatural qualities of what they are witnessing, because their implications are world-shattering and insanity-inducing. 6/17
1 reply
0 recast
4 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
Literary examples of the fantastique genre include HP Lovecraft, Jorge Luis Borges, and Edgar Allan Poe, whose well-grounded characters experience abnormality in subtle and inconclusive ways, as well as a growing sense of cognitive dissonance when they hopelessly try to preserve rationality using Occam's Razor. 7/17
1 reply
0 recast
5 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
"Réalisme fantastique", however, belongs with neither the réaliste nor fantastique genres, and instead occupies an idiosyncratic no man's land between them. It is also not exactly science fiction, which is rationally speculative but not supernatural, nor is it fantasy, which uncritically takes for granted a supernatural world. 8/17
1 reply
0 recast
4 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
So what is réalisme fantastique, really? It started off with a nonfiction book published in 1960 by two journalists (Jacques Bergier and Louis Pauwels) under the name "Le Matin des Magiciens" (released four years later in English under the title The Morning of the Magicians). The goals of the book were to challenge mainstream views on paranormal topics such as alchemy, ancient spacefaring civilizations, cryptozoology, occultism, and ufology; and to exercise the readers' critical thinking abilities. 9/17 PDF of the book in English: https://shorturl.at/fRbHN
1 reply
0 recast
3 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
In their book, Bergier and Pauwels wrote (translation from French is my own): "Fantastique" is generally defined as a violation of natural laws, as the intrusion of the impossible [into reality]. For us, this is not at all what fantastique is. It is a manifestation of natural laws, a byproduct of perceiving reality directly, and not filtered through the veil of intellectual laziness, habits, prejudices, and conformism. 10/17
1 reply
0 recast
3 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
The co-authors of the book were heavily inspired by an American writer named Charles Fort who, for years, had obsessively documented testimonies of uncanny phenomena such as cryptid sightings, UFO encounters, anomalous objects falling from the sky, etc. culminating in the publication of his Book of the Damned in 1919. 11/17 PDF of the book: https://shorturl.at/Yxm6f
1 reply
0 recast
4 reactions
Thomas pfp
Thomas
@aviationdoctor.eth
"Le Matin des Magiciens" was a massive success (more than a million copies sold in France alone). It spawned a popular magazine, Planète, that for ten years covered topics such as epistemology, futurology, fantastique fiction, etc. Modern descendants from that magazine include Omni in the UK and Wired in the US. It also set the stage for multiple conferences dedicated to fringe research, scientific skepticism, zeteticism, etc. 12/17
1 reply
0 recast
4 reactions