I'm starting to feel like not everything should be an erc20. But...

Erc20s are great tech for ideas in their broadest sense.

Most media seems to represent a smaller portion of an idea.

One example: artwork -> art project -> artist -> art guild.

Which is best represented by an erc20?

All can be, but it seems some form of validation is helpful the more specific you get.

1155z is a bit bizarre. Zora's implementation isn't it, and it requires an additional layer of complexity over just 1155 or 20. Perhaps too much friction.

I forget where this was going gn lol

Strat/art/design. Thoughts: /user-steen Director: /enjoy Guild: /metaliminal

I make meals into masks and then eat them.🥪 /foodmasku 🌈 rc.xyz/foodmasku 🗽

That part is indeed elegant. The biggest blocker for me is no contract structure for organization. Maybe it's not important, or maybe there are work arounds. It's hard to argue against 20 as the most flexible, frictionless standard

gn ... I was thinking too ... The promise of royalties in NFTs - that was a lie. But trading fees can be like royalties. So strange to think that the solution for people who want royalties could be fungible tokens 😆

Do'er of things, sometimes artist | Support @ /zora | Father of @byiris | Handler of @botto | Owner of a Farcaster tatoo

no doubt that the pseudoroyalties are a huge unlock, it's just more friction than just 20 or just 1155 (even if 1155 is illiquid). if it only works on a handful of platforms, it's not going to click as easily. 

20 has proven to be completely frictionless, but it doesn't work perfectly for media. i suspect that's more a function of sales mechanics than anything. 

token sales, vs launching a single-side lp or doing a tradeable bonding curve could work better. and of course, media and metadata are limited w 20

I tend to agree, but I think something overlooked is that the z implementation ensures that royalties are always paid when something is traded within the pool.

We've made sure that the post<>erc1155<>erc20<>ETH flow is as simple as possible on our side so to you it's just buying and selling a post. Other platforms are welcome to show the process, and some do, but I think that takes away from the magic that we have.