design critiques

Alright, roast it

Wallet selection view has no personality. Also too many button styles in the mix but not sure I care.

Screen 1:

- Title: Add NFT title (Proof of Cocoa) to maintain context from the notification.
- Emphasis: Downplay the greeting and emphasize the NFT title to prioritize the content.
- Brand Color: Excessive use of brand color can be overwhelming. Use it sparingly on significant elements to maintain brand identity.

designer / programmer / data / web3 surfer

Central Jakarta, Central Jakarta City, Jakarta, Indonesia

Screen 3:

- Button Styles: Instead of disabling the external wallet button, use your secondary button style for it and your primary style for the Magic Wallet button. This provides clearer visual distinction.
- Title: Change "Mint to" to "Claim to" for consistency with the action initiated via the claim button.

Screens 3-4:

- State Pages: Assume you'll design state pages (claiming in progress, error states) to account for various scenarios.

Screen 4:

- Call to Action: Simplify by having one primary action button, secondary actions can be presented as less prominent text links below.
- Banner: Reduce the prominence of the DevShop banner. Consider replacing it with a text-based link for a lesser distraction
- Brand Color: ref Screen 1

Screen 2:

- Flow: Swap screens 2 and 3 to first ask about the preferred claim method (external wallet or Magic Wallet). This allows skipping email authentication for external wallets.
- Email Authentication: Avoid auto-signing in without user consent. Emphasize and obtain explicit approval before proceeding.